Color and Texture Variability in PET | TAO Food and Treats
Customers sometimes ask why different batches of food and treats look different from the previous batch. It’s a legitimate question. If the food looks different, you may wonder if the ingredients are the same or if a packaging error occurred.
Understanding raw ingredients, cooking, moisture, and food coloring helps explain color and texture variability in PET | TAO food and treats.
Key Takeaways
- Raw ingredients: Supply, season, growing conditions, and the cuts of meat used can affect appearance and moisture.
- Color: PET | TAO does not use food coloring in its products.
- Canning: Preheat time, temperature, and ingredient moisture influence the finished texture.
- Binders: Guar gum and carrageenan absorb and distribute moisture. The original product information explains PET | TAO’s use of guar gum in canned dog food and its former use of carrageenan in discontinued canned cat food.
- Freeze-dried products: An animal's age, exercise, meat preparation, and storage can affect the appearance of food and organ treats.
What Causes Variability in PET | TAO Food and Treats?
Many customers are used to their pet’s premium food appearing the same in every can or bag. Many pet food companies make sure the food appears the same in every can.
There’s a reason pet food companies do this: “consumer expectancy.” When customers open a can of pet food, they expect it to consistently look a certain way. They expect it to look the same.
However, canned food consistency comes with a price: binders. Manufacturers must add binders and food coloring agents to make a uniform product. Binders reduce pet food variability.
PET | TAO’s goal is to produce the highest quality pet food available for the optimal health of your dogs and cats. They choose to omit ingredients that do not support their mission.
PET | TAO is natural pet food. Variable moisture content and color result from their choice not to include artificial ingredients in their foods. However, this choice can confuse consumers and prompt questions.
Why Raw Ingredients Fluctuate
Pet food production starts with raw ingredients. The ingredients differ daily depending on factors such as supply and time of year.
Different Turkey Cuts Have Different Moisture and Color
For example, turkey thigh trimmings may be available one day but turkey wings the next. Both ingredients have distinct differences in moisture content and color. Both are turkey, yet they are different in appearance and texture.
Vegetables Change With the Season
Have you ever noticed the difference in the tomatoes at your local farmer’s market? During different times of the year, vegetables can vary depending on growing method, season, soil quality, and other factors.
How Food Coloring Creates Consistency
The only way to have consistent color from can to can and batch to batch is to add food coloring agents.
Food coloring additives, with caramel color being the most popular, are on almost every label of canned pet food sold in the U.S.
Food coloring assures each can or bag of food looks the same, regardless of the raw materials or cooking reactions occurring within the can. Without food coloring agents, color inconsistency is inevitable.
PET | TAO does not use food coloring in any of their products.
How the Canning Process Affects Moisture
Canning involves a multi-step process. First, the ingredients are ground and mixed in a large hopper.
Then the mix goes through pre-heating. During pre-heating, the raw ingredients release most of their moisture, which drains out of the hopper.
The amount of water released depends on three factors:
- Preheat time: How long the ingredients are preheated.
- Preheat temperature: The temperature used during preheating.
- Raw ingredient moisture: The moisture content of the starting ingredients.
All three factors vary from batch to batch and sometimes even within each batch. Therefore, it is impossible to make the process consistent 100% of the time.
Controlling Moisture During the Canning Process
Binders enhance volume, firmness, and texture. They help make the end product look the same, batch after batch.
Binders are added during the pre-heating phase to absorb and distribute water released during cooking. The cans are then filled and cooked. During cooking, the binder absorbs more water.
The most common binders in pet food are guar gum and carrageenan.
Binders make canned foods appear more homogeneous and less “soupy,” with a “potted meat appearance” after cooking.
Why Water Can Collect Around the Food
When binders are not added to meat-based canned products, water accumulates at the periphery of the can after cooking. This happens because the meat and vegetables shrink during cooking.
The same process happens when you cook these ingredients on a stove. The meat and veggies shrink as the water evaporates.
The amount of water generated is variable and depends on the moisture content of the raw ingredients, cooking time, and cooking temperature.
Remember, you can control water content only by adding binders to absorb and distribute moisture.
Carrageenan and Guar Gum
What Is Carrageenan?
Carrageenans come from red edible seaweeds. Pet food manufacturers frequently use carrageenans for product thickening and stabilizing.
Peer-reviewed journal articles, independent food safety agencies, and international review panels indicate carrageenan is safe in infant formula and food, including organic food.
The small group of researchers who disagree often use data not accurately representing the way carrageenan is consumed.
In some early studies, the test material is unspecified. These studies used a test material called poligeenan, which is never used in food.
Studies in which food-grade carrageenan was fed to animals in appropriate, low amounts confirm the safety of carrageenan.
However, on November 18, 2016, the National Organic Standards Board voted to remove carrageenan from the list of approved substances labeled “organic.”
Because extensive studies have proven its safety, some of our canned cat food products contained carrageenan. However, we discontinued our canned cat foods because they were not selling.
What Is Guar Gum?
Guar gum is the ground endosperm of guar beans. The guar seeds are dehusked, milled, and screened.
Scientists have extensively studied the physiological effects of guar gum on animals and humans.
In rats, the only significant effect of guar gum was reduced body weight and lower blood glucose, even in quantities over 100 times the FDA Acceptable Daily Intake.
Other studies show guar gum adds fiber to the diet and may help normalize blood glucose and cholesterol.
In addition, specific animal studies indicate guar gum is not carcinogenic or teratogenic.
Because extensive studies have proven its safety and health benefits, we are currently using guar gum in our canned dog foods.
We still choose to avoid food colorings because of possible side effects.
Variability in Freeze-Dried Raw Food and Treats
It’s perfectly normal to have color variability in freeze-dried raw pet food and organ treats.
Several factors can affect color. Proteins, the age of an animal, the amount of exercise it gets, and the storage of meat determine the color.
- Animal age: Older animals’ meat, liver, and kidneys will be darker than those of younger animals.
- Exercise: Exercised muscles are always darker in color, which means the same animal can have variations in muscle color.
- Preparation and storage: The color and texture of meat and organs may change during preparation and storage.
Personalized TCVM Guidance
If you ever feel like you need extra help choosing food therapy for your pet or supporting your pet naturally with TCVM herbal blends, we can help.
TCVM Pet Supply co-founding veterinarians Dr. Marc Smith and Dr. Casey Damron offer TCVM telemedicine consultations.
A consultation provides personalized recommendations specific to your pet, including:
- Evaluation: TCVM evaluation.
- Nutrition: Food therapy recommendations.
- Herbal support: TCVM herb recommendations and veterinary authorization.
- Supplements: Supplement recommendations.
- Additional care: Alternative medicine recommendations.
If you reside in the Middle Tennessee area or would like to commute, you may choose an in-clinic appointment instead.
You can learn more about each veterinarian and contact the clinic you prefer directly:
- Marc Smith, DVM, MS - Natchez Trace Veterinary Services
- Casey Damron, DVM, CVA - White Oak Animal Hospital
We hope this information helps you and wish you the best in helping your pet feel better. If you have any other questions or if we can help you in any way, just let us know!
Frequently Asked Questions
Why can two batches of PET | TAO food look different?
Raw ingredients vary with supply, season, growing conditions, and the cuts of meat available. Cooking and ingredient moisture also affect the finished appearance. PET | TAO does not use food coloring to make every batch look identical.
Why does moisture vary in canned food?
Preheat time, preheat temperature, and the moisture content of raw ingredients affect how much water is released. Cooking time and temperature also contribute. Binders absorb and distribute that moisture, while food without binders can have water collecting around the edges as meat and vegetables shrink.
Does PET | TAO use guar gum or carrageenan?
The original product information explains that guar gum is used in canned dog foods. Some former canned cat food products contained carrageenan, but those canned cat foods were discontinued due to lack of sales. The article discusses the origins, research, and uses of both binders above.
Why do freeze-dried food and organ treats vary in color?
Animal age, exercise, proteins, and meat storage influence color. Meat and organs from older animals tend to be darker, and exercised muscles can differ in color even within the same animal. Preparation and storage can also change color and texture.
The Bottom Line
Color, texture, and moisture variability in PET | TAO food and treats reflect differences in raw ingredients, cooking, and preparation. PET | TAO’s choice not to use food coloring also allows natural color differences to remain visible. Understanding these processes helps explain why one batch may not look exactly like the next.
See PET | TAO Food Therapy Products
Interested in trying a TCVM herbal formula? Submit Your Authorization Request or Request a TCVM Telemedicine Consultation




